Last night, the President articulated his (and many others) ignorance of science:
A hopeful society has institutions of science and medicine that do not cut ethical corners, and that recognize the matchless value of every life. Tonight I ask you to pass legislation to prohibit the most egregious abuses of medical research — human cloning in all its forms … creating or implanting embryos for experiments … creating human-animal hybrids … and buying, selling, or patenting human embryos. Human life is a gift from our Creator — and that gift should never be discarded, devalued, or put up for sale.
What he want’s to say is that we shouldn’t be creating half-human/half-pig abominations of nature with twisted science gone awry. Instead, what he end’s up saying is that the use of human genes in animals should be ÂÂÂbanned and that if there is an animal gene that corrects Down syndrome or Parkinson’s, it shouldn’t be used because that would be a human-animal hybrid. Of course, his fear is well grounded in TV shows like Seinfeld, but the reality of the situation is much more complex.
But it brings up a good question. What defines “humanâ€. Chimpanzees contain 98% of the same genes as humans. If we were to add or change the remaining two percent to match the human genome, would the chimp be a hybrid? The definition of “human†is a label we have created to identify our species, but the distinction is not so clear cut as main-stream science would have us believe. Take, for example the Tasmanian wolf. It looks like a wolf but it’s not. It’s not even part of the canine family. It’s a marsupial, but it looks like a wolf, hence the name. In fact it’s Latin name, Thylacinus cynocephalus, means pouched dog with wolf head. It’s an artificial categorization of a creature that falls short of telling what it actually is.
Names and classifications are distinctions created by humanity to give order to the world. Nature has no concept of dog or human. It doesn’t recognize species or linage. There are no animal or plants. There is no living or dead. At least not as far as nature is concerned. Instead it’s all the same thing, just different forms.
So I look at what the President said, I have to chuckle. “[C]reating human-animal hybrids†is about calming the fears generated by late-night B-movies, with images of a half-man/half-fish creature preying on the innocent maiden as she swims in the lagoon; or alien/human hybrids with an uncontrollable urge to procreate. It’s a fear of a child who looks at those movies as if they were real.